Cozy up with this playful fall-themed “Would You Rather” — perfect for readers, librarians, and anyone who loves autumn vibes.

Just for Fun: Fall “Would You Rather” Edition 

Fall is finally here — the air is crisp, the sweaters are out, and the scent of apples and pumpkin spice fills the air!

Instead of a serious post this week, I thought we’d have a little fun together with a Fall “Would You Rather” game.

Grab your favorite drink, settle in with a cozy blanket, and let’s see how your fall favorites stack up against mine! Don’t forget to share your answers in the comments — I love hearing what other fall lovers think.

*This post contains affiliate links. If you click on and purchase an item from those links, I may receive a small commission.*

Apples vs. Hayrides: Which Fall Adventure Wins?

I’d have to say apple picking! There’s something magical about walking through rows of apple trees with a crisp breeze in the air. I’m lucky enough to live near The Elegant Farmer here in Wisconsin — home of the world-famous Apple Pie Baked in a Bag (trust me, it’s as amazing as it sounds!).

Hayrides are fun too, but they always feel more like a family activity — and as a single gal, I’m happy with my basket of apples and warm cider in hand!

Comfy Chic: Sweaters vs. Boots — The Ultimate Fall Fashion Dilemma

Why not both? A cozy sweater, skinny jeans, and tall boots are my fall uniform. Honestly, can any Midwestern girl even choose between them? They’re the perfect pair — like pumpkin pie and whipped cream!

Spooks or Feasts: Which Holiday Reigns Supreme?

I have to admit — Thanksgiving wins for me. As a youth services librarian, Halloween is busy: from not-so-scary storytimes to family trivia nights and our library’s annual Trunk-N-Treat, it’s nonstop fun but a lot of work!

Thanksgiving, though, is my chance to relax, eat delicious food, and recharge before the December chaos. Plus, hello — mashed potatoes and pie!

Wands vs. Witches: The Magic Showdown! Harry Potter vs. Halloweentown

Come on, is this even a question? Harry Potter, of course! It’s pure fall magic.

Curl Up or Create: Reading vs. Writing Edition

Reading, always! But I’ll admit — fall also gets my creativity flowing. There’s something about a chilly day, a candle, and a notebook that makes writing feel extra cozy.

Warm Cup Wars: Cocoa vs. Tea

Definitely hot cocoa! I’m not a fan of caffeine, so tea and coffee are out for me. My favorite cozy concoction? Swiss Miss Salted Caramel Hot Cocoa K-Cups mixed with a splash of Peppermint Mocha Creamer — hello, Peppermint Mocha Caramel Heaven!

Sticky Sweet Showdown: Candy vs. Caramel Apples

I’ll admit it — I’ve never had a candy apple! So caramel apples are my go-to treat. And if you want a fun twist, I highly recommend caramel apple pops — they’re pure nostalgia!

Witching Hour Flicks: Which Fall Movie Tops Your List?

It’s Hocus Pocus for me! Fall just isn’t complete without the Sanderson sisters causing chaos in Salem. I usually watch it more than once (okay, maybe a lot more than once).

Other fall favorites: Sleepy Hollow, The Addams Family (1991 version), and Casper. What’s on your Halloween watchlist?

Spells or Spirits: Who’s Your Fall Favorite?

I’m team witch, of course! I’ve dressed up as one more than a few times — it’s effortless and timeless.That said, I do love a good ghost story. My favorite spooky podcast is Two Girls One Ghost — if you like eerie tales and haunted history, you have to check it out!

What About You?

Now it’s your turn! Which would you rather?

Tell me your answers in the comments — and if you want even more fall fun, check out this Pinterest list of 48 Fall “Would You Rather” questions.